In the ever-evolving world of decking materials, a wide array of options have emerged, challenging the conventional use of natural wood. Plastic decking, designed to resemble weathered wood, once seemed like the future of decking. However, the landscape is shifting.
After closely examining numerous exhibits at the International Builders Show in Orlando, Florida, it became evident that a multitude of composite decking companies were vying for attention. Among them were well-known brands and several international contenders, including those hailing from China. Despite their elaborate displays and glossy marketing materials, it was a common sight to witness attendees approach various representatives with a set of recurring questions:
- How does this compare to authentic hardwood like Ipe?
- What about the recalls related to issues like mold, peeling, and cracking? How does your product differ?
- Could you disclose the chemicals used to prevent fading, as claimed?
Clearly, consumers have been diligently researching these decking materials. Considering the less-than-stellar track record that composites have established, it’s reasonable that skepticism is on the rise regarding the touted low maintenance of these alternatives.
Each time, I overheard representatives provide variations of the same answers, but often without satisfying clarity. Merely asserting that a product is “better” because it’s made from recycled materials doesn’t offer a comprehensive explanation. Similarly, withholding information about the chemicals used in the production of plastics raises concerns, especially in light of the numerous recalls and quality issues plaguing foreign-made construction products.
However, the most glaring issue with these options is the undeniable fact that composite and PVC decking carries an unmistakable plastic appearance. No matter how hard they try to mimic the authenticity of real wood decking, it remains an elusive goal. If a product claims to surpass the qualities of natural wood, it must demonstrate resilience against the harshest elements that mother nature can unleash.
For example, consider the enduring beauty of the Brazilian Ipe deck showcased by the beach in the image above. It has gracefully weathered the daily onslaught of sun, rain, foot traffic, wind, sand, and every conceivable environmental challenge for years, remaining remarkably intact. This resilience contrasts starkly with the online reviews and accompanying images of composite decking failures. Given the historical performance of composites, the future outlook appears less than promising.
Have you ever contemplated replacing your composite deck, or are you considering building a new deck in the future? What attributes are you seeking in your choice of decking material? Share your insights and preferences with us in the comments section below.
